SECOND CHANCE ACT (H.R. 1593 / S. 1060)
What it is: The Second Chance Act of 2007 (H.R. 1593 / S.
1060) is bipartisan legislation introduced by Danny Davis (D-IL) and others in the House, and
Senators Joseph Biden (D-DE), Arlen Specter (R-PA), Sam Brownback (R-KS), Patrick Leahy (D-VT)
in the Senate. The bill would provide assistance to states and localities to implement
strategic plans for providing and coordinating comprehensive efforts to enable juvenile and
adult ex-offenders to successfully reenter their communities. Such efforts include access to
supports and services such as: family reunification, job training, education, housing,
substance abuse and mental health services. The bill would also provide for research on
reentry and create a national resource center to collect and disseminate information on best
practices in offender reentry.
How it works: The U.S. Department of Justice would administer demonstration
grants to states and local governments to provide and coordinate reentry programs for
juvenile and adult offenders.
Why it’s important: The transition of juvenile offenders from confinement
to "life on the outside" presents great risks and opportunities for young people and
society. Juveniles released from confinement still have their likely "prime crime years"
ahead of them. Perpetrators over age 17 commit 85% of all violent crimes and young adults
aged 18 to 21 account for a greater percentage of crime than any other four-year age group.
Unsuccessful transitions into the community result in an alarmingly high recidivism rate for
juvenile offenders of 55-75%.
Effective reentry programs can reduce recidivism rates. These programs provide the support
and resources needed to guide ex-offenders through a successful transition from confinement
to community life. Comprehensive reentry programs are especially effective among young
people. With their development still in progress, young ex-offenders are more amenable to
effective behavior modification interventions, thus saving lives, anguish, and public tax
dollars. An example of a research-based, effective program that has a strong reentry
component and reduces recidivism is Multidimensional Treatment Foster Care (MTFC). MTFC
provides services to youth and their families during and after a youth's out-of-home
placement, ongoing supervision by a program case manager, and frequent contact and
coordination of services with the youth's parole/probation officer, teachers, work
supervisors, and other involved adults. Compared to juveniles in residential group homes,
youth in MTFC averaged half as many repeat arrests and spent 59% fewer days incarcerated.
Overwhelming unmet need: In recent years there have been approximately 100,000
juveniles (ages 17 and under) in custody nationwide. The vast majority of these troubled
youths will be released back into the community, with their expected "prime crime years"
ahead of them and facing recidivism rates of up to 75%. Many young people are released
unconditionally when they "age-out" of juvenile court jurisdiction, without access to family
reunification or aftercare services, increasing the likelihood that they will return to
crime. In 2002, approximately 150,000 juvenile offenders were placed out-of-home, and
nearly 400,000 others were placed on probation. Some juvenile offenders must be placed in
secure custody to protect public safety, and many others are first-time offenders who will
not become repeat offenders and therefore are not high-risk enough to justify the expense
and intrusion of the aforementioned programs. But even if only half of those on probation
and half of those placed out of home are eligible for these effective intervention programs,
the number of young offenders who could benefit from evidenced-based approaches would still
amount to 7 times the 35,000 total currently being served by MST, FFT, and MTFC. In other
words, these programs will have to expand 7 times their current capacity nationwide before
they start running out of youth who could and should be receiving these services.
Fiscally responsible: Research-based reentry programs such as MTFC not only reduce
crime, they are also cost-effective. MTFC saves taxpayers and crime victims roughly $78,000
per juvenile treated.
Recommendation: Fight Crime: Invest in Kids recommends that Congress move the
legislation to enactment, and then fund it at the authorized level, to facilitate the
implementation of comprehensive research-based reentry programs for juvenile and adult
offenders across the nation that can help make our communities safer.
For more information, please contact Miriam Rollin at (202) 776-0027
ext. 143 or miriam@fightcrime.org.